BluePoint Digital Marketing Review — Oct/Nov 2025

Bi-monthly digital marketing review covering paid advertising, SEO, and operational issues. Meeting led by Melissa Cusumano and Mark Hope (Asymmetric) with Wade Zirkle and Mike Stebbins (BluePoint ATM).

Meeting recording: https://fathom.video/calls/502959976

Overview

Overall performance was strong on a blended basis, but a mid-period budget cut and campaign pauses caused a measurable November decline. The headline story is the exceptional SEO domain rating jump and the decision to pause LinkedIn and redirect spend to Google Ads PMAX.

Key Decisions

1. Pause LinkedIn ads; reallocate budget to Google Ads PMAX. LinkedIn produced only 3 direct form fills at $1.85 CPC over two months. Mike Stebbins noted no inbound leads had ever cited LinkedIn as a source. Decision made to pause immediately and redirect spend.

2. Reactivate "Cashless ATM" campaign with geo-targeting. Wade proposed targeting states with cannabis legalization but no cashless ban mandates (e.g., New Mexico). Asymmetric to implement geo-exclusions so "cashless ATM" keywords only run in appropriate markets.

3. Keyword strategy: retain "cashless ATM" as a capture term, not a content term. Users searching for reverse ATMs often don't know the correct terminology. Decision: continue bidding on "cashless ATM" to capture misdirected intent, but ensure all landing page and blog content uses "reverse ATM" to avoid product confusion.

4. PMAX budget to increase. The 33% budget cut (from $90/day to $60/day) in November correlated directly with a conversion drop. Recommendation to restore and potentially increase PMAX budget using reallocated LinkedIn spend.

5. LinkedIn lead gen forms for future relaunch. When LinkedIn is reactivated (particularly for the Stadiums & Arenas vertical), use native LinkedIn lead gen forms to reduce friction for busy professionals rather than directing to a landing page.

Google Ads Performance

PMAX Campaign

• October: 84.7 conversions — top-performing campaign
• November: Conversions declined after a 33% budget cut ($90/day → $60/day); campaign appeared budget-constrained
• PMAX uses AI to test ad types across search, display, and YouTube simultaneously — functions as "reconnaissance" in early months to identify what converts
• Typical lifecycle: run PMAX for first 6–12 months, then shift budget to proven campaign types

Paused Campaigns

• "Traditional ATM" and "Cashless ATM" search campaigns were paused in November, contributing to the overall conversion decline alongside the PMAX budget cut

Google Ads Access

• Mark Hope noted a domain-restriction security setting was blocking Wade's access invitation; to be resolved post-call
• BluePoint team has read access; Asymmetric prefers they not make changes directly to avoid unintended consequences

SEO Performance

Domain Rating Growth

• DR jumped from 29 to 37 in 30 days — a gain Mark Hope described as exceptional, noting some clients don't move that much in two years
• Attributed to a focused backlink strategy: "pick three things and push hard" rather than spreading effort across ten tactics
• Higher DR directly improves Google Ads rank (ad rank ≈ domain rating × bid), making this a force multiplier for paid performance
• Site health score: 100/100

Monthly Traffic

• October: 205 sessions, 26 conversions, 3.53% conversion rate; 7,800 impressions, 256 clicks
• November: Sessions and CTR declined, partly due to algorithm fluctuations and the keyword pivot away from "cashless ATM"

Content Optimization

• Top-ranking blog post: "How Reverse ATMs are changing the way we pay" — currently has a 1–1.5% CTR
• Action: replace stock images with original visuals and add a prominent CTA button to improve conversion from organic traffic
• Next content cluster: build topic clusters under "Reverse ATM" as the primary keyword hub

LinkedIn Ads Performance

• Carousel ads outperformed video: 13 vs. 6 conversions (LinkedIn-defined conversions, not form fills)
• Geo-targeting was limited to Virginia and Colorado with audience expansion enabled
• LinkedIn's attribution challenge: users frequently see an ad, then search directly rather than clicking through — making direct ROI measurement difficult
• Mark Hope's framing: LinkedIn functions as an awareness/impression-share channel, not a direct-response channel; meaningful evaluation requires 6+ months
• Decision: pause now. After two months, direct ROI is insufficient to justify $1.85 CPC when Google Ads PMAX is budget-constrained

Technical & Operational Issues

HubSpot Lead Sync — CRITICAL

• Website form submissions are not automatically syncing to HubSpot; leads require manual entry
• Root cause unknown; Melissa to run form submission tests across all pages to diagnose
• Wade and Mike to test all website forms and report results

CallRail Outbound Dialing — RESOLVED IN CALL

• Wade reported calls were ringing back on his own phone instead of connecting to the intended recipient
• Resolution demonstrated live: CallRail's outbound dialing works by first ringing the caller's own device; the caller must answer their phone, and then the system connects to the recipient
• Separate issue: CallRail admin credentials not stored in LastPass — Wade to add
• Wade to send a written summary of remaining CallRail issues to Melissa and Mark for configuration follow-up

Unexplained Website Changes — URGENT

• Logo and slogan have been removed from the site
• Incomplete copy saves observed
• Source of changes unknown — possible unauthorized access or CMS user error
• Wade to investigate, restore logo/slogan, and implement access controls

Stadiums & Arenas Email Campaign

• Campaign appears unsent in HubSpot with no delivery data visible
• Melissa to investigate status and report back

Clarity (Heatmaps) Access

• Asymmetric team was inadvertently locked out of Microsoft Clarity
• Mike restored access during the call to team@asymmetric.pro
• Next step: review mobile UX heatmaps; ~50% of BluePoint's traffic is mobile

Action Items

Asymmetric — Melissa Cusumano

• [ ] Pause LinkedIn ads and reallocate budget to Google Ads PMAX
• [ ] Reactivate "Cashless ATM" campaign with geo-targeting for non-ban states (e.g., New Mexico)
• [ ] Run HubSpot form submission tests across all pages; confirm auto-sync; report findings to Wade & Mike
• [ ] Investigate Stadiums & Arenas email campaign status and metrics in HubSpot
• [ ] Send next blog drafts with proposed images to Wade & Mike
• [ ] Schedule GoHighLevel training with Wade & Mike
• [ ] Provide final cost estimate for direct mail campaign (including postage)
• [ ] Pull and share full-year Meta ads performance data

Asymmetric — Mark Hope

• [ ] Fix Google Ads domain-restriction security setting; grant Wade access

Asymmetric — Full Team

• [ ] Prepare 2026 marketing strategy and OKRs for next meeting

BluePoint — Wade Zirkle & Mike Stebbins

• [ ] Send final webinar/website changes to Asymmetric for implementation
• [ ] Update "How Reverse ATMs are changing the way we pay" blog: replace stock images, add CTA to contact form
• [ ] Test all website forms to help diagnose HubSpot sync issue
• [ ] Investigate unexplained website changes; restore logo and slogan; implement access controls
• [ ] Send CallRail issues summary to Melissa & Mark
• [ ] Add CallRail admin credentials to LastPass

BluePoint — Mike Stebbins

• [ ] Restore Clarity access for team@asymmetric.pro (completed in call); then review mobile UX heatmaps and share findings

Context & Background Notes

On keyword terminology tension: Wade was firm that "cashless ATM" refers to a different product category entirely and should not appear in content. Mark and Melissa's counterpoint: searchers don't know the distinction and may use "cashless ATM" when they mean "reverse ATM." Resolution: bid on the term to capture intent, but never use it in content or ad copy in a way that implies BluePoint sells cashless ATMs.

On LinkedIn attribution: Mark explained the multi-touch awareness model — a prospect may see a LinkedIn ad, later Google the company, and convert via search. The LinkedIn ad gets no credit in last-touch attribution but contributed to the conversion. This is a real phenomenon but difficult to prove, and the team agreed the current spend level isn't justified given PMAX is budget-constrained.

On PMAX lifecycle: PMAX is explicitly a learning tool for the first 6–12 months. Once Google's AI identifies what converts, the team will shift to targeted campaign types. Cutting the PMAX budget prematurely (as happened in November) interrupts the learning cycle.

On deal economics: Mark established that BluePoint's average deal value is ~$10,000/year with a 3–5 year customer lifetime (~$30,000–$40,000 LTV). This means even a $1,000 cost-per-acquisition would be highly profitable, giving significant headroom to invest in paid channels.

Attendees

Related

• ^[1]
• ^[2]
• ^[3]
• ^[4]